How potential market shifts are affecting homeowners insurance

Fallen tree on a damaged house.
Adobe Stock.

With insurance premiums on the rise and policy changes becoming more frequent, homeowners across the country are finding it more and more expensive to protect their properties. The key reason behind this is – insurance companies are changing their policies and pricings according to several factors including: inflation, particularly after the pandemic, climate change, increasing material and construction costs and shifting market dynamics.

Understanding the insurance market is essential to manage expenses effectively without having to worry about the coverage of costs.

In this article, we'll break down the reasons behind the soaring premiums, regional market outlook, how these changes are impacting homeowners, and adaptive strategies to help navigate the rising insurance costs.

Factors behind the rise in insurance premiums

Multiple factors are increasing insurance premiums. Let's explore the key influencers.

· Inflation and higher materials cost

Inflation is increasing insurance premiums as the cost of construction materials (up to 30-50% since 2020) and labor is significantly increasing, which means expensive replacement and repair costs. Resultantly, insurers have to pay more for claims which contributes to the surge in insurance rates.

· Climate change and frequent natural disasters

Climate change is one of the major influencers of soaring insurance premiums. Natural disasters such as hurricanes, tornadoes, wildfires and droughts are getting more frequent, causing widespread property damage. This results in higher damage coverage, rebuilding costs and claims paid by insurers.

· Reinsurance costs and adjustments

Reinsurance or insurance that insurance companies buy from other companies to manage risks and capital has also become more costly. As a result, insurance companies are transferring these expenses to homeowners resulting in higher insurance premiums for them, with some states experiencing a 40% rise.

· Frequent and fraudulent claims

A recent increase in claims due to natural disasters as well as fraud claims have increased pressure on insurers. Fraudulent claims increase costs for everyone, which leads to stricter underwriting policies. According to the FBI, fraudulent claims cost insurers approximately $30 billion annually.

How insurance premiums vary by states

The increase in insurance premiums also varies by region, with some states experiencing higher surges compared to others. States that have the highest insurance increase are:

  • Florida– $6,642
  • Louisiana–$4,693
  • Nebraska–$4,100
  • Oklahoma–$4,027
  • South Dakota–$3,797

Homeowners living in coastal and disaster-prone (approx. 40% of the population) states such as Florida, California, Texas, and Alabama are more vulnerable than others, requiring separate insurance policies.
Additionally, urban areas may see higher crime-related insurance premiums, whereas in rural areas it's due to limited access to emergency services and longer response time.

Impacts of rising insurance premiums on homeowners

Rising insurance premiums are impacting homeowners the most both directly and indirectly. Since homeowners are paying more for their insurance premiums, it is affecting their overall monthly budget, leading to individuals cutting expenses, especially for those with fixed incomes.

Texas real estate expert Brady Bridges commented, "In high-risk areas, homeowners may struggle to find insurers willing to cover their property, resulting in them turning to state-backed insurance, which may be more expensive. Rising insurance costs also mean higher mortgage rates, which puts a financial strain on homeowners."

The rise in insurance rates can also discourage potential buyers which affects property value. Due to this, some states are experiencing slow real estate growth, making it difficult to sell homes.

For homeowners, understanding the costs associated with selling a house is just as important as managing rising insurance premiums.

Strategies for managing insurance premiums

Homeowners need proactive strategies to manage insurance costs while maintaining adequate coverage. Here are some effective ways to navigate the increasing insurance premiums:

Find the right insurance agent and rates

One of the most effective ways to manage rising insurance premiums is to find and compare insurance rates from different insurers, as it can vary significantly between providers. Consider working with an independent insurance agent or broker who can access various policies from different insurers and provide expert advice.

A risk management expert or broker can also help identify cost-saving opportunities by assessing a property and recommending improvements which can lower insurance costs.

Enhance home resilience

Improving a home and making it more resilient can reduce damage. This includes upgrading roofing and windows, enhancing the fire safety system, reinforcing doors and structures, and implementing flood protection measures.

Increase deductible and understand policy coverage

Raising the deductible can decrease monthly premiums, for example, increasing a deductible from $500 to $2,500 can reduce premiums by 15-30%. Additionally, it is essential to review your insurance policy carefully to understand the coverage and exclusions to prevent further cost management risks.

Explore state and federal insurance programs

Homeowners struggling with rising insurance costs can look into the state and government insurance programs which can provide alternative coverage options. For example:

  • Fair Access to Insurance Requirements (FAIR) – For those in high-risk areas
  • National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) – For flood coverage in flood-prone regions
  • Community Development Block Grant Disaster Recovery (CDBG-DR) – For recovery from disasters

What's ahead for the insurance industry?

As the insurance industry keeps evolving, what does the future hold for homeowners and insurers?

Various trends and challenges are influencing the future of the insurance industry. Insurance premiums are anticipated to continue increasing over the next few years due to inflation (approximately 10-15% annually), climate change, and policy changes, making it more expensive for homeowners to ensure maximum coverage. Additionally, reinsurance costs are projected to increase 10-20% annually.

Insurers may also implement stricter underwriting policies, higher deductibles, and additional exclusions for high-risk properties, further restricting coverage options for homeowners.

However, technological advancements like AI, data analytics, and smart home devices will help in pricing and risk assessment. At the same time, it is anticipated that government interventions and new policies may be introduced to stabilize the market.

While the rise of insurance premiums, shifting policies, and increasing risks may seem overwhelming, staying ahead of the curve and making wise decisions will be essential for navigating these challenges. The future may seem unpredictable, nevertheless, homeowners can navigate the challenges and protect both their properties and finances with the right strategies.

For reprint and licensing requests for this article, click here.
Buying Insurance Property and casualty insurance Insurance plan premiums
MORE FROM DIGITAL INSURANCE