California issues eighth wildfire-based insurance non-renewal ban in 2024

Firefighter looks out at a fire seen over hills and mountains in distance
A firefighter with the Mill Creek Hotshots during the Line Fire in Big Bear, California, on Monday, Sept. 9, 2024. This fire led to a declared state of emergency and one-year insurance non-renewal moratorium issued by the California Department of Insurance on October 15.
Kyle Grillot/Bloomberg

A one-year moratorium on non-renewal of residential property insurance policies, issued November 14 by the California Department of Insurance and Commissioner Ricardo Lara, is just the latest of 34 such orders covering various areas since the practice began in 2019.

Ricardo Lara, California Insurance Commissioner
Ricardo Lara, California Insurance Commissioner.

The newest moratorium is for parts of Ventura County, California affected by the Mountain Fire, which led California's governor to declare a state of emergency for the area on November 7.

The moratoriums are part of a consumer protection law authored by Lara in 2018 as a state senator. The law requires the one-year moratoriums for any location where the governor has declared a state of emergency. They have been issued between July and November in each year, with eight so far in 2024, the highest number since nine were issued in 2021. According to the department, the moratoriums in 2024 before the most recent one collectively affect about 1 million policyholders.

Carmen Balber - Consumer Watchdog - from screenshot.jpg
Carmen Balber, executive director of Consumer Watchdog.
Consumer Watchdog

The commissioner's rate reform plan, which it calls the "Sustainable Insurance Strategy," has been controversial, and opposed by the consumer advocacy group Consumer Watchdog. 

"The one-year moratoriums are an important real-time protection against non-renewals in the wake of a serious wildfire," stated Carmen Balber, executive director of Consumer Watchdog, in an email response. "However, they aren't a long-term solution. For that, we have to prevent insurance companies from non-renewing anyone who protects their home from wildfires."

For reprint and licensing requests for this article, click here.
Regulation and compliance Climate change Weather and Climate Change Risk Property and casualty insurance
MORE FROM DIGITAL INSURANCE